What Is The Controversy With The Elf On The Shelf?

What Is The Controversy With The Elf On The Shelf?

The Elf on the Shelf is a popular Christmas tradition that has been around for over a decade. The tradition involves purchasing an elf doll that is said to be sent from the North Pole to watch over children and report back to Santa Claus about their behavior. However, the tradition has also been the subject of controversy, with some parents and experts expressing concerns about its potential negative effects on children.

The Pros of The Elf on the Shelf

Proponents of The Elf on the Shelf argue that it can be a fun and harmless way to get children excited about the Christmas season. They say that it can help to create a sense of magic and wonder, and that it can also teach children about the importance of good behavior.

Some parents also believe that The Elf on the Shelf can help to improve children’s behavior. They say that the elf’s presence can remind children to be kind, helpful, and respectful, and that it can also help to deter them from misbehaving.

The Cons of The Elf on the Shelf

Critics of The Elf on the Shelf argue that it can be stressful and anxiety-provoking for children. They say that the elf’s constant surveillance can make children feel like they are always being watched and judged, and that it can also lead to them feeling guilty or ashamed if they misbehave.

Some experts also believe that The Elf on the Shelf can promote unrealistic expectations about Santa Claus. They say that the elf’s presence can lead children to believe that Santa Claus is always watching them, and that he will only bring them presents if they are perfectly behaved. This can lead to children feeling pressure to be perfect, and it can also make them afraid of Santa Claus.

The Bottom Line

The decision of whether or not to participate in The Elf on the Shelf tradition is a personal one. There is no right or wrong answer, and each family should decide what is best for them. However, it is important to be aware of the potential pros and cons of the tradition before making a decision.

If you do decide to participate in The Elf on the Shelf tradition, there are a few things you can do to help minimize the potential negative effects. First, make sure to set clear expectations with your children about the elf’s role. Explain that the elf is there to help them get excited about Christmas, and that it is not there to spy on them or judge them. Second, be mindful of how you use the elf. Avoid using the elf to scare or punish your children, and instead focus on using it to create a sense of fun and magic. Finally, be prepared to answer your children’s questions about the elf honestly and openly.

Questions and Answers

• Q: Is The Elf on the Shelf a good way to teach children about good behavior?

• A: The research on this is mixed. Some studies have shown that The Elf on the Shelf can help to improve children’s behavior, while other studies have shown no effect. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to use The Elf on the Shelf to teach children about good behavior is a personal one.

• Q: Can The Elf on the Shelf be stressful for children?

• A: Yes, The Elf on the Shelf can be stressful for some children. The elf’s constant surveillance can make children feel like they are always being watched and judged, and this can lead to them feeling anxious or guilty.

• Q: How can I minimize the potential negative effects of The Elf on the Shelf?

• A: There are a few things you can do to help minimize the potential negative effects of The Elf on the Shelf. First, make sure to set clear expectations with your children about the elf’s role. Explain that the elf is there to help them get excited about Christmas, and that it is not there to spy on them or judge them. Second, be mindful of how you use the elf. Avoid using the elf to scare or punish your children, and instead focus on using it to create a sense of fun and magic. Finally, be prepared to answer your children’s questions about the elf honestly and openly.